Claims Reporting

Accident Fund
1-866-814-5598
ClaimsExpress@accidentfund.com
 www.accidentfund.com

Brethren Mutual Insurance Company
1-800-621-4264 (M-F: 8 am to 4:30 pm) 
1-800-241-2541 (After normal business hours)
csr@bmic.com

Builders Mutual Insurance Company
1-800-809-4862

Cincinnati Insurance Company
Workers Compensation - 1-877-242-2544
All Other: 1-513-870-2739
Claims@cinfin.com

Companion
1-877-379-7389

EMC Insurance Company
1-888-EMC-CALL (888-362-2255)

Hanover
1-800-628-0250
1-800-399-4734 (Fax)

Harford Mutual
1-877-445-5826

National Grange - Main Street America
1-877-425-2467
1-877-282=3844 (Fax)

One Beacon

1-877-248-3455 

Ohio Casualty
1-800-561-0178

Philadelphia 
1-800-765-9749
1-800-685-9238 (Fax)
onelineclaims@phlyins.com
https://www.phly.com/aboutphly/Claims/ReportClaimForm.aspx

Progressive

1-800-274-4499

The Hartford
1-800-327-3636
1-866-861-2513 (Fax)

Travelers
1-800-238-6225
1-866-878-4527 (Glass Only)